Current location - Recipe Complete Network - Catering training - Civil compensation in Shen Xuhua
Civil compensation in Shen Xuhua
At 20: 00 on August 1 2002, Shen Xuhua came out of Room 12 to answer the phone, opened the northeast access door on the second floor and fell from the second floor to the first floor. After that, Shen was taken to the hospital for emergency treatment. During the hospital rescue, the defendant Beijing Zhang Shengji Catering Co., Ltd. was responsible for providing lunch and dinner for Shen Xuhua's family. The defendant Jingzhe Hotel paid Shen Xuhua's medical expenses 160 164.45 yuan and Shen Xuhua's family accommodation 1 14938+0 yuan. On August 20th, 2002, Shen Xuhua died after being rescued.

On June 3rd, 2003, the case of Shen Xuhua, the host of CCTV's "Sunset Red", which attracted much media attention, reached the first trial result. Chaoyang Court found that the defendant Zhang Shengji Restaurant and Jingzhe Hotel should be held responsible for the accident, and awarded the defendant compensation of RMB 387,639.

According to the tripartite statement, the on-site investigation record, the criminal science and technology appraisal book of Beijing Public Security Bureau, the receipt of forensic appraisal fee, the receipt of funeral expenses, the receipt of transportation expenses, the certificate and the court trial record.

Beijing Chaoyang Court held that the defendant Beijing Zhang Shengji Catering Co., Ltd., as the operator of the catering industry, should provide consumers with services that meet personal safety requirements. The wooden door on the northeast side of the second floor of the restaurant is connected to a passage. There are all kinds of miscellaneous items such as ladders, control irons and triangle angles in the passage. After entering the door, it hangs directly at the east side 40 cm, without lighting equipment. The court ruled that the two defendants failed to pay attention to the incident and failed to take preventive measures, and should be responsible for the damage caused by Shen Xuhua's death. According to the law, the two defendants were sentenced to compensate the plaintiff for forensic appraisal fees, funeral expenses, transportation fees, civil aviation airport management and construction fees, and mental damages totaling more than 248,000 yuan; Compensate the plaintiff for alimony of 72,000 yuan; Compensation for the plaintiff Yu Boyang's childcare fee of 67,200 yuan. Defendant Beijing Zhang Shengji Catering Co., Ltd. and Defendant Beijing Jingzhe Hotel each compensate 50% of the above compensation amount and bear joint liability.

The two defendants failed to notice the incident and took no preventive measures, so they should be liable for the damage caused by Shen Xuhua's death. The court ruled that the two defendants * * * compensated more than 380,000 yuan according to law. This is an old-fashioned accident of eating people to death at the construction site. It is said that the construction of the construction site is "for the destruction of construction", but the silent trap of the construction site "destroys" people's lives. Only "destruction" does not mean "construction", and it is impossible to be "construction" any more.

It is not so much that the construction site eats people, but rather that the construction management kills people-the safety problem of the construction site is seriously out of control and has become a "management black hole". If engineering construction is "a century-long plan, quality first", then the construction process must be "construction plan, safety first".

Safety management, first of all, is a question of consciousness, then a question of system, then a question of implementation and supervision. However, in this chain of consciousness, system, implementation and supervision, not to mention a link, in many places, half a "ring" has not been "generated". These security measures are usually easy to implement.