the system of compulsory serviceman
Conscript system means that the state stipulates by law that male citizens must perform military service for a period of time after reaching a certain age to ensure national security and stability. The advantage of the compulsory soldier system is that it can ensure a sufficient number of military personnel, and at the same time, it can also cultivate the patriotism and military quality of the people. However, there are also some problems in the compulsory soldier system. First of all, the compulsory soldier system will limit the freedom rights of citizens. Secondly, the conscript system may cause some people to be unable to serve for personal reasons, thus affecting the security and stability of the country.
Volunteer system
Volunteer system means that the state guarantees the number of military personnel by recruiting volunteers. The advantage of the volunteer system is that it can protect citizens' freedom rights, and at the same time, it can give those who are interested in serving the country the opportunity to join the army. However, there are also some problems in the volunteer system. First of all, the volunteer system may lead to a shortage of military personnel, which will affect the security and stability of the country. Secondly, the volunteer system may cause some people to fail to join the army for personal reasons, thus missing the opportunity to serve the country.
comparative analysis
From the advantages and disadvantages of the above two systems, we can see that the compulsory soldier system and the volunteer system have their own advantages and disadvantages. The following will compare and analyze these two systems from the following aspects.
Implementation difficulty
The implementation of the compulsory soldier system is relatively difficult, because the state can force citizens to serve through legal provisions. The implementation of the volunteer system is relatively difficult, because the country needs to attract volunteers to join the army through publicity and incentive mechanisms.
Personnel quality
The quality of conscripts is relatively low, because conscripts are often forced to serve, and they may not have enough military quality and patriotism. The quality of volunteers is relatively high, because volunteers join the army voluntarily, and they usually have high military quality and patriotism.
Quantity guarantee
The compulsory soldier system can guarantee the number of military personnel, because the state can force citizens to serve through legal provisions. The volunteer system may not guarantee the number of military personnel, because the number of volunteers may be insufficient.
social influence
The system of conscripts imposes certain restrictions on citizens' freedom rights, which may cause social dissatisfaction and resistance. The volunteer system can guarantee citizens' freedom rights and is conducive to social stability and harmonious development.