1. The two have nothing to do with each other. They are both civil organizations that oppose the Qing Dynasty and restore the Ming Dynasty.

2. Heaven and Earth will be real in history. Tiandihui, one of the private secret societies in the Qing Dynasty. It is named after worshiping heaven as father and earth as mother. Also known as Hongmen, commonly known as Hongbang. There are several different opinions on the time when Tiandihui was founded, and there is no conclusion yet. Initially, most of its members were farmers or small handicraftsmen transformed from bankrupt farmers, small traders, transport workers along the land and water transportation lines, and other wanderers without fixed occupations. Since then, the composition has become increasingly complex, but it is still dominated by poor people from the lower classes. The Tiandihui used slogans such as resisting the Qing Dynasty and restoring the Ming Dynasty, obeying the will of heaven, robbing the rich and giving to the poor, etc., which reflected the national concepts of the people at that time and their demands against class oppression. Before the fall of the Qing Dynasty, it played a huge historical role in the Han people's resistance to the bullying and oppression of the Manchus. effect.

The Heaven and Earth Society in Jin Yong's novel appeared in "The Deer and the Cauldron" and was created by Chen Jinnan.

3. The Red Flower Club is an anti-Qing group in Jin Yong's novels "Book of Swords" and "Flying Fox", and its leader is the chief rudder Chen Jialuo. According to Jin Yong himself, the Red Flower Club was created by him and there is no such thing in history.

4. In Jin Yong's novels, these are different gangs in two different books. "The Deer and the Cauldron" and "The Book, Sword and Enmity" are not related in themselves, so the people and things in them are not related. The connection is normal. Even if their various situations are very similar, they are still two different individuals and have no connection.