What Eileen Chang said here, "The Red Mansion is not finished" refers to Cao Gong only wrote the first eighty times, to "the beauty of the Xiangling yielded to the stick of the greedy husband, Wang Daoshi made up the envious woman Fang" will end abruptly, I do not know what to follow, which is also the same on the Osprey sequel to a kind of This is also a kind of dissatisfaction to Gao Osprey's sequel. Such an incredibly fascinating and beautiful story, such a red and green and strange Grand View Garden, that inhabited by the Goddess of Mercy and the Jiangzhu Immortal Grass Yihongyuan, Xiaoxiang Pavilion and then no whereabouts, as the ancient state of Loulan, generally, was obliterated in the yellow sands, which really let all the people read the 80th time to feel an endless emptiness and attachment. Although the current "Dream of the Red Chamber" will be Gao Osprey to add the last forty times, but because it is not Cao Gong pen ink, or let a person feel a deep regret.
However, I personally believe that such a regret, but more can become the "Dream of Red Mansions" of the greatest charm, the abrupt end of the story, more people can leave unlimited space for reverie, so that each of us love the "Dream of Red Mansions" of the hearts of the people have their own "Grand View Garden of the ending". "A thousand readers have a thousand Hamlet" story, always more exciting than a definite set to come.
What's more, in 1791, Cheng A book "Dream of Red Mansions" added Gao Osprey's continuation, which also shows that the readers at the time of this forty times of recognition, after all, even if it is a modern day us, put down the prejudice against the continuation of the book, just hold a literary appreciation of the attitude of who will not be in the "Lin Daiyu burning manuscripts to break the infatuation" time cover your face sad, who will not be in the Who would not weep when "Lin Daiyu burned the manuscript to break her infatuation", and who would not weep when "the bitter Jiangzhu soul returned to the heaven of hatred"? We will all be very angry with Feng's final "kill" Xiaoxiang consort's scheme, and feel the impermanence of the world's events in the end of the twelve Jinling hairpins. The final jade belt hanging in the forest, the final sound dream, after the wrongdoing to pay off the scene and the same is so saddening.
We all feel that the first eighty Cao Gong arrangements such as God's help, written "to explore the hairpin Daiyu half-containing acid," "tearing the fan as a smile of a thousand dollars," "the pretty maid to hold the wrong premature flow of wind," and so on. "and so on or heartbreaking, or make people smile, or make people tearful description, too much to attract readers, those poetic works, including the jinling twelve hairpin's respective judgment, all let all the love of poetry can not stop, but, high osprey's work, but the same to do to be able to touch the readers of the heart, in addition to the pillow xia's end of the old friend xiangyun and the baoyu's In addition to the end of the pillow Xia's old friend Xiang Yun and Baoyu's ending seems to be somewhat not Cao Gong predetermined, the other whether the style or plot, are basically on the road of Cao Gong, is not also a good one to fill in the writing? The first thing I'd like to say is that I don't want to be a part of the team, but I want to be a part of the team.
In fact, this will see half of the book on the reluctance to continue to see the situation often occurs, and this situation often appears in the book after a particular event, for example, some people say that "Guan Yunchang scraped the bones to heal the poison, Lv ZiMing white across the river," as well as "Xu GongMing war in the shinshui, Guan Yunchang For example, some people say that after "Guan Yunchang scraped his bones and healed the poison, Lu Ziming crossed the river in white" and "Xu Gongming fought in Shinshui, Guan Yunchang lost the city of wheat", there is no more Three Kingdoms after that, and there is no more Liang Shanbo after "Liang Shanbo divided the gold and bought the market, and Song Gongming was recruited by the whole group", and so on, and this is not without a certain degree of truth. However, if this is the reason for thinking that the contents of the book are "unpleasant", then there is indeed some prejudice. Indeed, there is no Guan Yu of the Three Kingdoms of the situation immediately changed radically, after the recruitment of Liang Shan Po will lose its soul, but, again, we appreciate is the whole twist and turns of the storyline, rather than in line with the reader's inner trajectory of the development of the stereotypes of the novel, which is the reason why the four masterpieces of the four masterpieces of the reason, imagine, if the Three Kingdoms ultimately Liu Bei under the five tigers generals to rule the Three Kingdoms, the Liang Shan Po of the good guys topple the three masterpieces of the four masterpieces of the four masterpieces of the four masterpieces of the four masterpieces. If the five tigers under Liu Bei had ruled the Three Kingdoms, and the heroes of Liang Shan Po had overthrown the Northern Song Dynasty, would such an obvious compromise with the readers' wishes have pushed Romance of the Three Kingdoms and Water Margin up to the rank of the Four Great Masterpieces?
So, "Red Mansions" is not a hateful thing, because, has been identified as Cao Gong pen and ink of the first eighty times to bring us the emotional richness of enjoyment, sighing the ups and downs of the life situation has allowed us to feel the infinite charm of such a masterpiece, the Gao Osprey's continuation of the book can also be the same to us to bring the feeling of beauty, under the pen of a different person, poignant beauty has a different flavor, as readers. As readers, have the "Book of Stones", have the "Dream of Red Mansions" is a great fortune, unfinished novel, leaving us with an unfulfilled reverie, with "birdsong mountain even more quiet" unceasingly the noise of the remote realm.
What's more, it is not possible to conclude that the last forty books were really written by Gao Osprey. Mr. Hu Shi initially put forward such a point of view, the basic basis is one, and the first time since the words do not fit, two, Shi Xiangyun's throw away. However, looking at these two points alone is a bit one-sided, initially 1791 Cheng A book in the red chamber, Cheng Weiyuan and Gao Osprey said, "so that the disjointed and disorganized after forty and the first eighty synthesized into a whole, complete, that's all, there is no other? To its original text, did not dare to change, do not want to cover its original face. If Gao Osprey continued, why do they have to go to great lengths to cover it up? Yu Pingbo in the late dying words "Hu Shi, Yu Pingbo waist cut Red Mansion guilty, Cheng Weiyuan, Gao Osprey preservation of the Red Mansion has merit" also shows that the "new red" one of the representatives of the ultimate disapproval of their own previous and Hu Shi with "Dream of the Red Mansion" of the The first is that it is not a good idea to have a good time, but a good time.
All in all, as a reader, I think, regardless of the "Dream of Red Mansions" finished, this should not be a hate thing, we finished "Dream of Red Mansions" should have a sequel to the flaws to appreciate this miracle of the mentality, and the unfinished "Stone Chronicle", we should also feel that the infinite imagination, but also the birthplace of our inspiration, can give rise to more profound thinking.
The wine scattered people left the scene, sober people are the most ridiculous.