To discuss this issue, we must first look at who the Five Tigers killed: Guan Yu killed Cheng Yuanzhi, Hua Xiong, Guan Hai, Xun Zheng, Yan Liang, Wen Chou, Kong Xiu, Meng Tan, Han Fu, Bian Xi, Wang Zhi, Qin Qi, Cai Yang, Yang Ling, Xia Houcun, Cheng He, * * * Ji1 Zhang Fei's beheading records include Gao Sheng, Cao Bao, Ji Ling, Chen Sun, Lv Xiang, Xia Houlan, Xiahou Jie and Zhou Shan, including 8 people.

The military commanders killed by Zhao Yun include Juyi, Pei Yuanshao, Gao Lan, Zhang Wu, Lv Kuang, Chun Yudao, Xia Houen, Yan Ming, Zhong Mao, Zhong Shen, Xing Daorong, Liu Qin, Mahan, Murong Lie, Jiao Bing, Zhu Ran, Jin Huan Sanjie, Han Ying, Han Qiong, Han Qi, Han De and Zhu.

Ma Chao beheaded four generals, namely Wang Fang, Li Tong, Ma Wan and Liang Xing, and seven brothers from Yang Fu were killed by Ma Chao.

Deng Xian, Han Hao, Xia Houyuan and Shi Ji were the generals killed by Huang Zhong.

The record here includes all the records of the five tiger generals who killed the enemy immediately, by foot and by bow and arrow. Zhao Yun is the ultimate killer, with the most generals killed, followed by Guan Yu, Ma Chao, Zhang Fei and Huang Zhong. However, if the quality of the slaying record is concerned, it is still Guan Yu. Yan Liang, the military commander killed by Guan Yu, once defeated Xu Huang in 20 rounds, which can be regarded as a superb military commander in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms.

Wen Chou and Yan Liang are equally famous. They once drew with Zhao Yun and defeated Xu Huang, which is also a super-class rank. Hua Xiong's level can be regarded as first-class or quasi-first-class, and there is also a Guan Hai who fought Guan Yu for dozens of rounds before being killed, and this level can also be regarded as quasi-first-class. Ji Ling, the military commander killed by Zhang Fei, once fought Guan Yu for 30 rounds, which was also considered a brave general.

Zhaoyun beheaded the most records, but only one Gao Lan once drew with Xu Chu, which can be considered as a first-class military commander or quasi-first-class, and the others are not famous. Xia Houyuan must have the highest gold content in Huang Zhong's slaying of military commanders, and Xia Houyuan was among the first-class military commanders in The Romance of the Three Kingdoms. Compared with Li Tong, who was killed by Ma Chao, the others were worse. Therefore, according to who killed the military commanders, Guan Yu was the first, followed by Huang Zhong, Zhao Yun, Zhang Fei and finally Ma Chao.