Current location - Recipe Complete Network - Complete vegetarian recipes - Debate whether dog meat should be banned.
Debate whether dog meat should be banned.
Rule 1: Should we eat dog meat?

Now I want to talk about my views on eating dog meat.

Let me make it clear first: I seem to have eaten dog meat once when I was a child. But for personal reasons, I don't eat dog meat now. Also out of personal feelings, I don't eat fish eggs yet. In case someone says I'm speaking from my own standpoint.

My hometown is in a village in Jiaodong. I lived in the countryside until I was 16 years old, then I lived in the county for 4 years, and then I came to Beijing and lived for 10 years.

I had a dog at home when I was a child. What is a dog? Dog is one of the six animals, and it ranks with cattle, horses, sheep, pigs and chickens. Its main function is to guard the home and protect the hospital. Anyway, at that time, there was basically no concept of "pet" in our concept, and livestock were raised for usefulness. Therefore, all my domestic dogs are for guarding the home. Of course, if you keep it for a long time, you will be reluctant to eat it, but this feeling is not unique to dogs, and other livestock also have feelings.

The breeding speed of dogs is relatively fast. It can breed about 2-3 litters a year, usually 5-6 per litter, so there is no shortage of dogs. Some people kill their domestic dogs and eat them. The dog meat I ate as a child seems to be my uncle's dog. I remember that at that time, people often rode bicycles from village to village just to collect dogs, and the collected dogs were naturally slaughtered and eaten. One of my two dogs was to show my uncle the orchard, and then he died of old age. The other one seems to have been sold. The collected dog was tied to the side of the bicycle, and the dog was foaming at the mouth. If the dog lovers see it now, they will definitely be scolded. But we also have chickens there, and the chickens we receive are also to be eaten. The chicken is tied to a bicycle and hung upside down. It makes a little whine from time to time and looks much more pitiful than the dog. These scenes are absolutely invisible to dog lovers.

I write this, which means that the number of dogs is not as much as that of chickens, and it is not regular meat, but it is very common for people to keep dogs and eat dog meat. On the contrary, people will buy beef to eat, but few people will kill their own cattle to eat. What we think of dogs, this situation.

Later, someone came to raise a dog specially, and the dog was a meat dog specially used for slaughter. I have heard of many people who get rich by raising dogs. Dog farms are not as good as raising cattle and sheep, because the cost of raising dogs is still relatively high. From the food chain, dogs are one level higher than chickens and sheep. The nature of dog meat determines that it cannot be a daily meat like pork, and the demand is not so great. Therefore, the scale of the dog industry as a whole is not that big.

I like dogs very much. As long as family conditions permit, I would rather have a dog than eat dog meat. But I still think eating dog meat is no more barbaric than eating beef. Some people keep dogs to be pets, while others keep dogs to eat meat, which is understandable.

These days, it was screened by Yulin Dog Meat Festival, and many people scolded the whole family for eating dogs. I don't think this is a reasonable attitude. I admire animal protectionists very much, and I even agree with most of their views. However, I can't agree to just take out the dog and say that other meat can be eaten, only dog meat can't be eaten. The relationship between animals and people is special. For example, dogs can guide the blind, but cows can't. On the other hand, cows can plow fields, and dogs can't. Why can we eat beef but not dog meat? Besides, training a guide dog costs so much, who wants to eat it? Therefore, eating dog meat and beef does not mean that whose morality is more noble.

Some people define dogs as "companion animals" to distinguish them from other animals and give them the right not to be eaten. I want to say that cattle can also be defined as "servant animals". In China's native concept, it seems that only pigs and sheep are "eaten". If we can emphasize the particularity of dogs, we can also emphasize the particularity of cows and donkeys. Everyone is special, so don't eat.

A casual search for "meat dogs" on the Internet reveals that the industry of raising meat dogs is no longer a small industry, and it is found in almost all provinces. There are many dog meat restaurants in Beijing, but eating dog meat is not a unique tradition in Guangxi. Moreover, there are many records of eating dog meat in ancient novels, so people who are good at this bite are not new in recent years. Some people say that almost all the dogs killed in Yulin Dog Meat Festival are stolen pet dogs. I don't know if they have investigated it and said it is true. Let's just say that this is true, and this is no reason to ban dog meat. Why should people be forbidden to eat dog meat when someone steals dogs? According to their thinking, is it forbidden to keep dogs when dogs bite?

Others say that eating dog meat is uncivilized according to foreign standards. I can only say that the world is so big that everyone's menu is so different. If you take other people's habits as the standard, there are too many things you shouldn't eat. They didn't eat crabs, pig offal or stinky tofu before. Indians don't eat cattle, Muslims don't eat pork, and Jews in Israel don't eat shellfish and scaleless fish. Everyone has something he likes and something he doesn't like. Why is it civilized for you to eat beef and uncivilized for me to eat dog meat?

I think people who like to keep small animals have the right to keep your favorite animals. For example, if you have a dog, as long as you don't let the dog bite, your rights should be guaranteed. Even if your dog comes out to bite, you still have the right to keep a dog as long as you take care of it after paying compensation. Similarly, I also think that people have the right to eat meat. As long as you don't eat rare animals, steal or rob, eating meat should not be scolded to death by the whole family.

Dog lovers should be rational and understand that "loving dogs" is their own feeling. People are not born with the obligation to "love dogs". I quite agree with some slogans of dog lovers, such as "Love it is to take care of it for life" and "Don't dislike it, don't dislike it", but "People who eat dog meat will kill the whole family" and "Curse to be a dog in the next life" are not included. Keeping a pet is a very caring thing, but if you want to kill someone else's whole family, it's a bit crazy.

If dog lovers are willing to listen to advice, they are only asking the government to strengthen the management of the dog meat market, make the dog meat market as standardized as pork market and beef market, slaughter it legally, improve quarantine and prevent those stolen dogs from entering the market. It is unreasonable to demand that dog meat be banned. Indiscriminate abuse will not solve the problem, but will pollute the reputation of dog lovers. Didn't the so-called "dog slave" title come from those brain-dead dog lovers themselves?

Article 2: Should we eat dog meat?

I remember once driving to Yunfu, Guangdong with some friends. On the highway, I met a truck full of dogs. It's an ordinary local dog, barking uneasily in the iron cage in the trunk. Considering the food culture in Guangdong, we know that these dogs are obviously not sent to cage shops. So my friend Ye waved angrily to the people on the truck. As a result, the other party thought we were playing tricks and waved to us happily. Just like a chicken talking to a duck. Why is there such a big difference between people?

There are two kinds of people who love dogs in the world. One is to treat dogs as pets, and the other is to treat dogs as food. The difference between them is as great as that between Martians and earthlings. For a long time, the pet dog pie and the dog-eating pie argued endlessly, and basically they all said their own words, just like chickens talking to ducks. Dog lovers say that dogs are friends of human beings, dogs are spiritual animals, and eating dog meat is barbaric; People who love dogs say that dogs are no different from cats, pigs, cows and sheep. They are all animals. Writing about eating dog meat is hypocritical. Sometimes, eating dog meat will be promoted to the height of national culture. During the 2002 World Cup in Korea and Japan, western NGOs strongly protested that Koreans ate dog meat, and even FIFA was involved. Faced with friendly and surprised voices, many Koreans angrily retorted that this was an interference with their traditional food culture. However, in order to run the World Cup well, Koreans finally put great restrictions on eating dog meat. China people also have a long history of eating dog meat. In history, Fan Kuai's occupation was killing dogs, so people in China began to eat dog meat at least before the Han Dynasty, and it seems to be industrialized and large-scale. For some reason, dog meat is not popular in the Central Plains, but it is carried forward in Guangdong and Guangxi. I don't know if it is the custom of the Central Plains or the legacy of South Guangdong.

As a nominal Cantonese, I have eaten dog meat. Dog meat tastes spicy and strong. It's a little creepy, but it tastes really good. "Shaolin Temple" said: Smell dog meat, even the gods jump over the wall. But one person's food is often another person's poison. For dog lovers, killing and eating dogs is like bereavement-no, it's like losing a son. However, logically, it is difficult to refute the dog-loving school. After all, all animals are equal. You can't think that eating some animals is a sin just because you prefer some animals, and eating other animals is a matter of course. It sounds really hypocritical. In this way, only vegetarians are qualified to blame people who eat dog meat. But vegetarians don't blame eating dogs, because they are against all killing. This is the weakness of dog lovers, so when they object to eating dog meat, they can only appeal to their feelings without giving too many convincing reasons.

On the other hand, however, we humans have never decided our actions only by logic-the most logical ones are often extremists and terrorists. Mencius said that a gentleman cooks far away, but he didn't say that a gentleman doesn't eat meat. Because of course, a gentleman can't help eating meat, but he always has the heart to kill. This unbearable heart is the source of goodness. People's psychology and behavior are always intertwined with rationality and sensibility, and they are biased towards one side and will inevitably go to extremes. Wang Yangming said: When I didn't see this flower, it died with my heart. When I came to see this flower, I understood its color for a while. I know this flower is not outside your heart. In other words, when we look at external things, we always have to put our own brand. There is no such thing as a purely objective vision. From this perspective, we can better understand and sympathize with the attitude of dog lovers.

The status of dogs in China's traditional culture has always been very low, but with the development of pet culture, cats and dogs are increasingly regarded as friends and partners of human beings and as spiritual animals. When we give animals some meaning, they are no longer just a kind of food in our eyes. Burning harps and cooking cranes spoil the scenery, because harps and cranes are elegant things. Similarly, a swan is much heavier than a duck in our mind; A dragon fish and a crucian carp are not the same thing in our minds. Therefore, the logical premise that all animals are equal is actually untrue to people. The only problem is that people have different views on the same thing, such as dogs. Lovers regard it as a child, and gourmets regard it as delicious. I once saw the annual picture of a news agency, and a monkey head was barbecued, which was quite shocking. If we can be indifferent to dog meat, should we treat monkeys and even orangutans who are closer to humans equally? I believe most people's answer is no, so we have a degree of problem about the likes and dislikes of animals. Between emotion and appetite, where should we stop? It is difficult to have a standard answer. I don't recommend eating animals such as cats and dogs. Because these animals are too close to our daily life, for most people, their good feelings have become a kind of synaesthesia, and eating them has become a rather unpleasant thing. When this unpleasant psychology can be transferred from bystanders to people who eat, perhaps fewer and fewer people will eat cats and dogs. Hoping to give up eating cat meat and dog meat has gradually become a psychological taboo for people.

Unlike Koreans, China people not only eat dog meat, but also all wild animals, such as snakes, pangolins, civets, lizards and owls. They fly in the sky and crawl underground. They eat all four legs except tables and chairs. Those with wings eat everything except airplanes. The reason for opposition is obvious, it is not environmentally friendly and hygienic. Besides these, is there anything worth reflecting on? Man is an omnivore in biology, and eating meat is an instinct. However, carnivores in the biological world just want to fill their stomachs. Probably, there is no such thing as human deliberately searching for smells. I doubt very much that Cantonese food preference is the heritage of Baiyue. Perhaps at that time, in the mountainous and hilly areas of the south, agriculture and animal husbandry had not yet developed, and there was no suitable food, so we could only feed on wild animals such as snakes, pangolins and civets in the mountains, thus forming this stubborn food culture. Of course, we don't advocate the Puritan way of life. The food we can get today is far more abundant and reliable than that of the ancients, and it is also a complication of various cooking techniques. However, after all, there must be a limit to the enjoyment of the mouth. Generally speaking, food should always be convenient, healthy and hygienic. In order to satisfy one's appetite, poor and boring, gluttony behavior that ignores hygiene and destroys environmental protection can not be regarded as a healthy and moral lifestyle. Confucius said, if you don't eat properly, you don't sit properly. I prefer to understand it as a dignified and healthy lifestyle here. We need to build a dignified and healthy food culture.

Article 3: Should we eat dog meat?

Should I eat dog meat?

Some time ago, a car full of dogs was stopped by animal protectionists on the highway, and the two sides were deadlocked for more than 10 hours. Finally, under the mediation of the police, the animal protectionists paid 10 million yuan to buy the dog in the car. It is 1, but it is far from over. Animal protectionists posted comments on the Internet, condemning the cruelty to dogs, and published some personal information, such as the photo of driver Hao and his mobile phone number. At this time, the waves rose again. Some people denounce eating dog meat as inhuman behavior, some people say it is a eating habit, and others are keen on Hao and so on.

Should dog meat be eaten after all? Can you eat it or not?

Animal protectionists righteously denounced eating dog meat as 1 inhuman practice. "Dogs have helped mankind and are friends of mankind. How can you bear to eat your friend's meat? " This seems reasonable, but it is absurd.

We usually eat pork, beef and chicken, but no one says how poor pigs are, how poor cows are and how poor chickens are. But why do some people object to eating dog meat? We should respect life except human beings, but that doesn't mean we can't eat meat. If we respect life according to some people's logic, pigs, cows, chickens and dogs can't eat it, then should all human beings be vegetarian? Also, even if you are a vegetarian, it is not enough. We grind and steam wheat and rice to make steamed bread, rice and various meals. Are we too cruel? We shouldn't eat them, because they are also life, because according to modern research, when trees are cut down, they send out angry and sad messages (instruments can measure them). Then all we can do is shut up and drink a little water every day. Also, you can't wear clothes and shoes yet, you can only be naked, because clothes and shoes can't be used as raw materials separately from other species. In the end, the end of mankind is only a dead end, hehe, how interesting.

Being a friend of mankind, the pig that raises the human body is not a friend, and the cow that raises the body and works hard for mankind is not a friend? Wheat is not a friend? Rice is not a friend? Why do we prefer one of them? Why are you talking about protecting dogs while chewing beef?

Eating dog meat is a 1 component of China's traditional food culture and a 1 element of its own culture, just like the French eating foie gras and the Spanish bullfighting. According to records, raising dogs in the Han Dynasty was as common as raising pigs today. It is an exaggeration to say that dogs have raised people in China, but dog meat has definitely raised people's bodies in China. In the view of Chinese medicine, dog meat is a good medicine, which has a nourishing effect on human body.

It is good to respect the life around you. However, the ethics of respecting life, even if it is moved out of its founder Shi Huaizhe, may not be clear, because it is a paradox in itself. Since there is life on the earth, since there are intelligent creatures in life, and since human beings stand out among intelligent creatures, there is an unequal relationship between human beings and other species, that is, human beings are the center of all life, and other species must serve human beings. This is the arrangement of the creator, and it is independent of human will. What mankind should do is to rationalize and harmonize this unequal relationship.

We should respect other lives, which is not only the embodiment of human kindness, but more importantly, the need for human beings to live in harmony with other lives and survive and develop. However, respect cannot be mechanically understood as not killing, and this concept cannot be generalized indefinitely. What we need to do is to grasp 1 degree. Danes often take a ruler with them when fishing. When they found that the fish they caught was very small, they set it free. The ancient Mencius also said, "No, fish and turtles are not allowed to eat." When an axe is like a mountain forest, wood can't be used. "Not don't eat, not don't need, but to have a degree.

Radish and vegetables have their own tastes, and the world is rich and colorful. You like dogs very much. Of course you don't have to eat dog meat. But you have no reason to ask others not to eat dog meat with you. There is no reason to criticize others for eating dog meat, saying that there is no humanity and no bad habits. It is a bad habit to think that you stand on the moral high ground and criticize other people's behavior. For the survival of mankind, some animals are to be killed as meat, but they should not be killed indiscriminately, let alone cruel. Life is precious, but when it is necessary to sacrifice some lives to ensure the survival of others, what we have to do is to be kind to those dedicated lives before they disappear.

Lively and lovely pet dogs can be kept, which can delight people's body and mind; Similarly, dog meat can be eaten as long as you like. Very beneficial to human body is 1 kind of meat.